You’ve probably heard about the hype surrounding eyebrow pencils and how they can transform your look. But with so many options out there, it can be tricky to find the right one for your unique brows. Luckily, we’ve done the research and rounded up the top-rated picks that deliver flawless, natural-looking results every time. From long-lasting formulas to ultra-fine tips, these eyebrow pencils are designed to make achieving your dream brows a breeze. Discover which one fits your needs and prepare to be amazed by the difference it can make.
Contents
- L’Oreal Paris Makeup Brow Stylist Definer Eyebrow Pencil, Medium Ash Brown
- Too Faced Pomade In A Pencil Eyebrow Shaper & Filler Taupe
- Anastasia Beverly Hills – Brow Definer
- NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil, Eyebrow Pencil – Espresso
- Benefit Precisely My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Brow Defining Pencil (Warm light brown)
- Factors to Consider When Choosing Eyebrow Pencils
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Can Eyebrow Pencils Be Used on Other Areas of the Face?
- How Long Do Eyebrow Pencils Typically Last Before Needing Replacement?
- Are There Any Tips for Using Eyebrow Pencils Correctly?
- Can People With Sensitive Skin Use Eyebrow Pencils Without Issues?
- How Do I Choose the Right Shade of Eyebrow Pencil for My Skin Tone?
- Conclusion
L’Oreal Paris Makeup Brow Stylist Definer Eyebrow Pencil, Medium Ash Brown
The L’Oreal Paris Makeup Brow Stylist Definer Eyebrow Pencil in Medium Ash Brown is an ideal choice for those seeking a precise, natural-looking brow filler that’s easy to use and long-lasting.
With its ultra-fine 0.5mm tip, this retractable pencil allows you to draw tiny brow hairs and fill in sparse areas with ease.
The waterproof formula stays put all day, never smudging or crumbling.
Plus, the super-soft spoolie brush helps blend and finish your brows for a polished, natural look.
Praised by Allure as a Best of Beauty winner, this affordable pencil compares favorably to more expensive brands, making it a go-to for many customers.
Whether you have medium blonde or dark brown hair, the versatile shade range guarantees you’ll find your perfect match.
Best For: The L’Oreal Paris Makeup Brow Stylist Definer Eyebrow Pencil in Medium Ash Brown is best for those seeking a precise, natural-looking brow filler that’s easy to use and long-lasting.
Pros:
- Ultra-fine 0.5mm tip for drawing tiny brow hairs and filling in sparse areas
- Waterproof formula that stays put all day without smudging or crumbling
- Super-soft spoolie brush for blending and finishing brows for a polished, natural look
Cons:
- Limited shade range, may not be suitable for all hair colors
- Some customers may prefer a pencil with a thicker tip for bolder brow looks
- Relatively affordable, but still a mid-range price point compared to drugstore options
Too Faced Pomade In A Pencil Eyebrow Shaper & Filler Taupe
For those with light complexions, the Too Faced Pomade In A Pencil Eyebrow Shaper & Filler Taupe offers a natural-looking brow that complements fair skin tones.
Users rave about the color, saying it works well with a light touch and leaves brows looking effortless.
Compared to other brow pencils, this one provides better control and definition than Benefit’s thicker option, and it lasts longer than the rounded Kylie Jenner pencil.
However, the product doesn’t always go on smoothly and can clump, and the quality seems inferior to Too Faced’s previous Brownie Eyebrow Pencil.
To get the best results, use light, short strokes and be mindful that the ‘dark brown’ may actually be a softer shade.
Overall, this pencil is a solid choice for those seeking a natural, customizable brow look.
Best For: The Too Faced Pomade In A Pencil Eyebrow Shaper & Filler Taupe is best for those with light complexions seeking a natural-looking, customizable brow.
Pros:
- Works well with a light touch, leaving brows looking effortless
- Provides better control and definition compared to other brow pencils
- Lasts longer than rounded pencils like Kylie Jenner’s
Cons:
- Product can break off and doesn’t always go on smoothly
- Little product in the pencil and tends to clump
- Quality is inferior to Too Faced’s previous Brownie Eyebrow Pencil
Anastasia Beverly Hills – Brow Definer
With its precise application and refined definition, the Anastasia Beverly Hills – Brow Definer is the ideal eyebrow pencil for those seeking a full, natural-looking brow.
Reviewers rave about its ability to fill in brows without appearing overbearing, making it a favorite among those with grey hair.
The versatile shade range, including the perfect ash brown for grey-haired beauties, guarantees you’ll find the perfect match.
While some find the pencil a bit on the firm side, it delivers long-lasting wear, even on oily skin.
When it comes to value, the Brow Definer is a steal, offering comparable quality to the pricier Estée Lauder pencil at a fraction of the cost.
Whether you’re looking to define, fill, or simply tame unruly brows, the Anastasia Beverly Hills – Brow Definer is a must-try product.
Best For: The Anastasia Beverly Hills – Brow Definer is best for those seeking a precise, refined eyebrow pencil that delivers a natural, full brow look, especially those with grey hair.
Pros:
- Fills in brows without appearing overbearing
- Versatile shade range, including the perfect ash brown for grey hair
- Delivers long-lasting wear, even on oily skin
Cons:
- May be a bit firm for some during application
- Potential for lose of eyebrow hairs, may require brow regrowth serum
- Does not last as long on oily skin, can come off when sweating or washing face
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil, Eyebrow Pencil – Espresso
If you’re seeking a budget-friendly eyebrow pencil that offers precise application and a natural finish, the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil in Espresso is an excellent choice.
This ultra-skinny pencil features a super-skinny retractable tip that allows you to fill in and define your brows with ease.
The cruelty-free, PETA-certified formula creates a natural-looking finish, perfect for those with sparse or over-tweezed brows.
Customers rave about the color accuracy and precision, though some note the pencil’s tendency to become brittle.
Available in a range of shades, the Espresso hue is a great option for those with cool or dark hair colors.
At an affordable price point, the NYX Micro Brow Pencil offers fantastic value, making it a go-to for precise, natural-looking brows.
Best For: The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil in Espresso is best for those seeking a budget-friendly, precise eyebrow pencil that creates a natural-looking finish.
Pros:
- Offers precise application and control
- Provides a natural, buildable look
- Affordable price point
Cons:
- Some customers report the pencil becoming brittle or breaking
- Shade names may be misleading, with some shades pulling red
- Can smudge or fade on oily skin
Benefit Precisely My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Brow Defining Pencil (Warm light brown)
The Benefit Precisely My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Brow Defining Pencil (Warm light brown) caters to those seeking a natural-looking, hair-like brow enhancement that lasts for up to 12 budge-proof hours.
With its ultra-fine tip, you can draw precise, feathery strokes that transform sparse brows into defined, filled-in ones.
The rich yet blendable color stays put, even in the face of water, and the built-in spoolie brush helps you achieve a seamless, natural look.
Users rave about the smooth application and easy control, noting that the Benefit pencil outperforms the Thrive brand.
While some find the quantity lacking, the Benefit pencil offers excellent value compared to department store alternatives, making it a worthy investment for effortless, long-lasting brow perfection.
Best For: The Benefit Precisely My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Brow Defining Pencil (Warm light brown) is best for those seeking a natural-looking, long-lasting brow enhancement.
Pros:
- Draws natural-looking, hair-like strokes
- Stays on for up to 12 budge-proof hours
- Smooth, easy-to-control application
Cons:
- Limited quantity
- Some users consider it not an original product
- Perceived as overpriced by some
Factors to Consider When Choosing Eyebrow Pencils
When choosing an eyebrow pencil, you’ll want to ponder the shade variety and undertones that suit your natural brow color.
The precision of application is key for creating defined, natural-looking brows, and the pencil’s longevity and wear-time will guarantee your look lasts.
Ease of use and control are also essential factors, as you want a pencil that glides on smoothly and allows you to fill in and shape your brows with confidence.
Shade Variety and Undertones
Selecting the right eyebrow pencil shade and undertone is crucial to achieving a natural, flattering look that complements your unique features.
When choosing an eyebrow pencil, it’s imperative to weigh the shade variety and undertones to guarantee a seamless match for your hair color and skin tone. Cool-toned shades with ash or blue undertones can help neutralize any redness or warmth in your skin, while warm-toned shades with golden or yellow undertones can enhance and complement your warm skin tones.
If you have dark or cool-toned hair, opt for pencils with cool-toned shades to avoid adding unwanted warmth or orange tones to your brows.
Keep in mind that undertones can dramatically impact the overall appearance of the pencil color, with some shades appearing more pink, purple, or orange depending on the undertone.
To find the perfect match, read reviews and check how the pencil looks on others with similar hair and skin tones as your own.
Precision of Application
Precise application is key when using eyebrow pencils, as it allows you to define and fill in sparse areas seamlessly.
For the most natural-looking results, look for a pencil with an ultra-fine tip, typically 0.5mm or smaller. This gives you greater control and precision, enabling you to create hair-like strokes that mimic the natural growth pattern of your brows.
A retractable or twist-up design is also helpful, as it guarantees you can maintain a sharp point throughout the application process. When filling in your brows, use light, short strokes for a more subtle, natural finish. Avoid heavy-handed application, as this can result in an overly done look.
The quality of the pencil’s formula is another important consideration. A soft or brittle lead that breaks or smudges easily can compromise the precision of your application. Opt for a pencil with a smooth, high-quality formula that glides on effortlessly for flawless, natural-looking brows every time.
Longevity and Wear-Time
A crucial element to ponder when choosing an eyebrow pencil is its longevity and wear-time, as you’ll want a product that lasts throughout the day without smudging or fading.
Look for formulas that are waterproof and resistant to oil, which can guarantee the color stays in place even in humid or sweaty conditions. Ideally, a good eyebrow pencil should last at least 8 hours, with some products boasting up to 12 hours of wear or more.
However, keep in mind that the longevity of an eyebrow pencil can also depend on your skin type. If you have oily skin, you may need to touch up your brows throughout the day, especially if you use heavy makeup removers.
The way you apply the pencil can also affect its wear-time, so be sure to follow the product’s instructions for peak results. By considering the longevity and wear-time of your eyebrow pencil, you can find a formula that keeps your brows looking flawless from morning till night.
Natural-Looking Finish
Achieving a natural-looking finish with your eyebrow pencil starts with selecting the right shade that complements your natural brow color.
Look for a pencil that allows you to create hair-like strokes, mimicking the direction and texture of your real brow hairs. Opt for a pencil with a fine, slender tip that gives you precise control for filling in sparse areas and defining the shape of your brows.
The key to a seamless, natural-looking finish is using light, short strokes. Avoid pencils that are too thick or have a rounded tip, as they can make it challenging to achieve a natural result.
Remember, the goal is to create the illusion of fuller, well-defined brows that still look like they’re your own.
Ease of Use and Control
When choosing an eyebrow pencil, you’ll want one that’s easy to handle and provides the level of control you need to define your brows.
Look for a pencil with a fine, precise tip, typically around 0.5mm, that allows you to create clean, defined lines and fill in sparse areas with ease.
The pencil should have a comfortable grip that lets you make smooth, steady strokes for a natural-looking application.
A retractable pencil can be more convenient than a traditional pencil that requires sharpening, as it eliminates the need for frequent sharpening and reduces waste.
Additionally, the pencil’s lead should be soft and smooth, gliding effortlessly across your skin for a flawless, even finish.
With the right eyebrow pencil that’s easy to use and control, you can achieve the perfect, natural-looking brows you desire.
Pigmentation and Coverage
In addition to ease of use and control, the pigmentation and coverage of an eyebrow pencil are essential elements to ponder when choosing the right one for your needs.
The ideal pigmentation should provide a natural-looking color that complements your hair color and skin tone.
Whether you prefer a sheer or full coverage, there are options to suit your desired look.
Some pencils offer a buildable formula, allowing you to customize the level of coverage to your liking.
However, keep in mind that the type of pigmentation can impact the pencil’s performance, with some formulas being more prone to smudging or fading throughout the day.
Ultimately, a good eyebrow pencil should deliver consistent color payoff and even coverage, without appearing cakey or artificial.
Affordability and Value
One of the key factors to ponder when choosing an eyebrow pencil is its affordability and value.
Prices can range widely, from under $10 to over $20 for a single product. When seeking a good value, look for a pencil that provides a natural-looking finish, is easy to use, and will last a decent amount of time before needing replacement.
Some pencils may cost more due to their high-quality ingredients, precise application tips, or long-lasting formula, making them a better investment in the long run.
Consider the amount of product provided, its durability, and the number of applications it can deliver before running out. Ultimately, the best eyebrow pencil for you’ll depend on your budget and the level of quality you’re willing to pay for.
Cruelty-Free and Ethical
Cruelty-free certification is an important consideration when choosing an eyebrow pencil, as it assures you the product hasn’t been tested on animals. Many popular brands, like NYX Professional Makeup, offer cruelty-free options, making it easier to make ethical choices. Opting for these products can help reduce animal testing in the cosmetics industry and promote more humane practices.
Some countries, like the European Union, have banned animal testing for cosmetics altogether. This means brands must adapt to cruelty-free procedures to stay competitive globally. By choosing cruelty-free eyebrow pencils, you can contribute to a larger movement towards ethical and sustainable beauty. PETA certification is a reliable way to identify products that align with your values.
When you buy cruelty-free, you’re supporting brands committed to ending animal suffering. This small decision can make a big impact, helping to create a more compassionate beauty industry. With so many ethical options available, there’s no reason not to choose an eyebrow pencil that’s kind to animals.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can Eyebrow Pencils Be Used on Other Areas of the Face?
Yes, you can use eyebrow pencils on other areas of your face. They’re versatile tools that can define and fill in sparse areas like the temples, nose, and even the upper lip. Just be mindful of the shade to guarantee a natural look.
How Long Do Eyebrow Pencils Typically Last Before Needing Replacement?
Eyebrow pencils can typically last 2-3 months with regular use, though it depends on how often you use them and how much product you apply. The longevity of an eyebrow pencil can vary based on your individual usage.
Are There Any Tips for Using Eyebrow Pencils Correctly?
When using eyebrow pencils, start by lightly filling in sparse areas. Feather the pencil’s strokes to create a natural look. Blend the pencil with a brow brush or spoolie to soften harsh lines. Finish by setting with a brow gel for long-lasting hold.
Can People With Sensitive Skin Use Eyebrow Pencils Without Issues?
With a bit of TLC, even folks with touchy skin can sport brow-tastic looks. Just be sure to patch test first and opt for gentle, hypoallergenic formulas. Soon you’ll be on your way to brow-fection!
How Do I Choose the Right Shade of Eyebrow Pencil for My Skin Tone?
To choose the right eyebrow pencil shade, match it to your natural brow color. Go a shade lighter if you have fair skin, or a shade darker for medium to deep complexions. Test it out to verify a seamless, natural look.
Conclusion
You’ll get flawless, natural-looking brows with these top-rated eyebrow pencils.
They offer precise application, long-lasting formulas, and a range of shades to suit your skin tone and hair color.
From ultra-fine tips to waterproof formulas, these products provide effortless, natural-looking definition and filler.
With a focus on precision, longevity, and ease of use, these eyebrow pencils are the ideal choice for polished, everyday brows.
