Skip to content

5 Best Too Faced Eyeshadow Palettes, Ranked and Reviewed in 2024

With over 2 million Instagram followers, Too Faced has become a beloved cosmetics brand known for its innovative eyeshadow palettes. While the company offers a wide range of options, some palettes stand out for their exceptional quality, versatility, and unique features. As you explore the brand’s lineup, you’ll discover a diverse array of shades, finishes, and formulas that cater to different makeup preferences and skin tones. From the creamy mattes of the Natural Matte Neutral Matte Eye Shadow Palette to the dazzling diamond-inspired hues of the Pretty Rich Diamond Light Eyeshadow Palette, these top-tier palettes promise to elevate your eye makeup game.

Natural Matte Neutral Matte Eye Shadow Palette

Natural Matte Neutral Matte Eye Shadow Palette

If you’re looking for a versatile, natural-looking matte eyeshadow palette, the Too Faced Natural Matte Neutral Matte Eye Shadow Palette is an excellent choice.

With its creamy, coconut butter-infused formula, the palette delivers rich, pigmented shades that blend effortlessly for an airbrushed effect, perfect for creating a range of everyday looks.

The updated palette features 7 new shades, along with 2 classic favorites, providing a well-rounded selection of neutral mattes.

The compact, purse-friendly design includes an oversized base shade for easy application, and the included Glamour Guide offers three starter looks to get you inspired.

The coconut-scented formula provides a smooth, comfortable wear, making this palette a must-have for matte eyeshadow enthusiasts seeking high-quality, natural-looking results.

Best For: The Too Faced Natural Matte Neutral Matte Eye Shadow Palette is best for matte eyeshadow enthusiasts seeking high-quality, natural-looking results for a range of everyday makeup looks.

Pros:

  • Creamy, coconut butter-infused formula delivers rich, pigmented shades
  • Blends effortlessly for an airbrushed effect
  • Compact, purse-friendly palette with oversized base shades

Cons:

  • Limited shade range with only 9 colors
  • May be too matte for some users’ preferences
  • Scented formula may not appeal to those sensitive to fragrances
  Get it now on Amazon.com

Too Faced Pretty Rich Diamond Light Eyeshadow Palette

Too Faced Pretty Rich Diamond Light Eyeshadow Palette

The Too Faced Pretty Rich Diamond Light Eyeshadow Palette is a shimmering must-have for those seeking a luxurious, long-lasting eye look with its multifaceted hues and easy-to-use glitter shades.

This 16-shade palette, inspired by real diamonds, delivers excellent pigmentation and impressive staying power, even on mature skin.

The well-constructed case guarantees ample supply, and the glitter shades stay put all day without the need for glitter glue.

While some customers reported receiving shattered palettes, the brand’s quality control should address this packaging issue.

Overall, this beautiful, user-friendly, and clubby palette comes highly recommended, offering great value for its reasonable price point.

Best For: Makeup enthusiasts seeking a long-lasting, high-quality eyeshadow palette with beautiful diamond-inspired hues and easy-to-use glitter shades.

Pros:

  • Excellent pigmentation and long-lasting performance
  • Versatile, multifaceted shades that work well on mature skin
  • Reasonably priced with great value

Cons:

  • Some customers reported receiving shattered palettes
  • Brand needs to improve packaging and quality control
  • Glitter shades may not be suitable for all occasions
  Get it now on Amazon.com

Too Faced Semi Sweet Chocolate Bar

Too Faced Semi Sweet Chocolate Bar

For those seeking a high-quality, neutral-brown eyeshadow palette with a delightful chocolate scent, the Too Faced Semi Sweet Chocolate Bar is a must-have.

The shadows are long-lasting and easy to blend, offering versatile color choices that range from natural to glam.

You’ll be impressed by the amazing pigmentation, as a little goes a long way.

While some shades may not show up well on darker skin tones, the black shade is the blackest and applies like gel.

The palette’s packaging is high-quality, with the color names written right on the palette.

Although it’s more expensive than other options, the quality and durability make it a worthwhile investment.

With fast shipping and good customer service, this palette is a fan favorite that you’ll likely use every day.

Best For: Those looking for a high-quality, neutral-brown eyeshadow palette with a delightful chocolate scent.

Pros:

  • Long-lasting and easy to blend shadows
  • Amazing pigmentation with versatile color choices
  • Delicious chocolate scent

Cons:

  • Some shades may not show up well on darker skin tones
  • The black shade is the blackest, but not all shades are as pigmented
  • More expensive than other eyeshadow palettes
  Get it now on Amazon.com

Too Faced Just Peachy Mattes Eye Shadow Palette

Too Faced Just Peachy Mattes Eye Shadow Palette

Perfect for those seeking a versatile, natural-looking eye makeup palette, the Too Faced Just Peachy Mattes Eye Shadow Palette offers a range of vibrant, blendable matte peach shades that deliver a cruelty-free, long-lasting formula.

With a lightweight, creamy texture that blends seamlessly, these eyeshadows can be applied with a light hand for a subtle, everyday look or built up for more dramatic, occasional wear.

Reviewers rave about the palette’s impressive quality, noting the colors’ depth and the formula’s excellent staying power without creasing.

While some users experienced packaging issues, leading to scattered powder, most were satisfied with their purchase, praising the palette’s lovely scent and exceptional value.

Overall, the Too Faced Just Peachy Mattes Eye Shadow Palette is a versatile and high-performing option for those seeking a natural, peach-toned eye makeup look.

Best For: The Too Faced Just Peachy Mattes Eye Shadow Palette is best for those seeking a versatile, cruelty-free eye makeup palette with a range of blendable, natural-looking matte peach shades.

Pros:

  • Vibrant, blendable matte peach shades
  • Lightweight, creamy formula that is long-lasting and smudge-resistant
  • Versatile for both subtle, everyday looks and more dramatic, occasional wear

Cons:

  • Some users experienced issues with packaging, resulting in scattered powder
  • Authenticity concerns from a small number of users
  • Potential for inconsistencies in product quality or packaging
  Get it now on Amazon.com

Too Faced Chocolate Gold Eyeshadow Palette, Cream

Too Faced Chocolate Gold Eyeshadow Palette, Cream

Makeup enthusiasts seeking a versatile, high-quality eyeshadow palette will find the Too Faced Chocolate Gold Eyeshadow Palette, Cream a mesmerizing choice.

Infused with real gold, the 16 shades deliver stunning metallic effects and velvety mattes that elevate any look.

The palette’s creamy formulas blend seamlessly and last all day, while the delectable cocoa scent adds a delightful sensory experience.

Reviews praise its vibrant, pigmented colors and easy application, making it suitable for a range of skin tones.

Although some users note the fragility and price, the palette’s overall performance and quality make it a worthwhile investment for those seeking an indulgent, multifunctional eyeshadow collection.

Best For: Makeup enthusiasts seeking a versatile, high-quality eyeshadow palette with stunning metallic effects and velvety mattes.

Pros:

  • Infused with real gold for extra sparkle
  • Creamy, blendable formulas that last all day
  • Delectable cocoa scent adds a sensory experience

Cons:

  • Some users note the fragility of the palette
  • The price point may be high for some consumers
  • The scent may not appeal to everyone
  Get it now on Amazon.com

Factors to Consider When Choosing Too Faced Palettes

When choosing a Too Faced eyeshadow palette, consider the scent and fragrance, as some contain cocoa or other sweet notes.

Assess the pigmentation and blendability of the shadows to guarantee they’ll perform well on your skin tone.

Also, look at the packaging and durability of the palette to see if it’ll hold up to regular use.

Scent and Fragrance

The scent-infused formulas in Too Faced eyeshadow palettes can captivate your senses, offering a multisensory experience that enhances your makeup routine.

Whether you prefer the brand’s signature chocolate-inspired fragrances or the delicate floral notes, the scents are thoughtfully incorporated into the products. For instance, the Chocolate Bar Palette imparts a rich, cocoa-infused aroma that evokes comfort and indulgence, while the Natural Eyes Palette features a more subtle, powdery scent reminiscent of fresh blooms.

You’ll find that the fragrances in Too Faced palettes aren’t overwhelming but rather pleasantly complementary, adding an extra layer of enjoyment to your eyeshadow application.

The brand’s attention to detail in this aspect guarantees that the scent never overpowers the pigmentation or blendability of the eyeshadows.

As you explore the diverse range of Too Faced palettes, consider how the unique fragrances might elevate your makeup experience and evoke a specific mood or emotion.

The scent can be just as important as the color payoff when selecting the perfect palette for your beauty needs.

Pigmentation and Blendability

Pigmented, blendable eyeshadows are the hallmark of Too Faced palettes, allowing you to create a range of eye looks with ease.

The rich, pigmented shadows deliver true color payoff, so a little goes a long way. You can build up the intensity for a more dramatic effect or sheer them out for a subtle, everyday look.

The silky-smooth formulas blend effortlessly, ensuring a flawless, airbrushed finish.

Excellent pigmentation and long-lasting wear are vital features of Too Faced eyeshadows.

They stay put throughout the day without running, fading, or streaking, so your eyeshadow look remains flawless from morning until night.

The versatile shade ranges also make it easy to mix and match colors to suit your individual skin tone and preferences, whether you’re going for a natural, neutral look or something more glam.

With their high-quality formulas and wide array of color options, Too Faced palettes offer the perfect blend of pigmentation and blendability for creating a variety of eye-catching looks.

Packaging and Durability

Properly protecting Too Faced eyeshadow palettes during shipping is essential, as packaging issues can lead to shattered shadows and other problems that may compromise the product’s quality and your overall satisfaction.

High-quality packaging, like the one found in the Too Faced Semi Sweet Chocolate Bar, can elevate the user experience with features such as color-coded names and a delightful scent.

However, some palettes, like the Just Peachy Mattes, may arrive with extra powder scattered throughout, underscoring the importance of secure packaging.

To prevent damage during transit, bubble wrapping and boxed packaging, as seen with the Chocolate Gold Eyeshadow Palette, Cream, can be effective safeguards.

Authenticity concerns may also arise if the packaging appears tampered with, so it’s pivotal to purchase from trusted sellers and inspect the product upon arrival.

Prioritizing packaging and durability when selecting Too Faced palettes can help guarantee you receive high-quality, well-protected makeup that lives up to your expectations.

Shade Range and Versatility

When selecting a Too Faced eyeshadow palette, carefully consider the shade range and versatility it offers, as these factors can substantially impact your ability to create a wide variety of eye makeup looks.

From the warm-toned hues of the Chocolate Bar palette to the cool-leaning shades in the Natural Eyes collection, the brand’s diverse color selections cater to different skin tones and personal preferences.

Some palettes, like the Born This Way and Natural Matte, boast a harmonious mix of matte and shimmery finishes, allowing you to achieve both subtle and dramatic effects.

Meanwhile, the Sweet Peach palette features an array of peachy, golden, and berry-tinged shadows, perfect for crafting fresh, summery looks.

The latest Born This Way The Natural Nudes palette even includes a spectrum of nude and neutral tones, granting you endless possibilities for everyday wearability.

Ultimately, the shade range and versatility of a Too Faced eyeshadow palette can profoundly influence the makeup looks you can create, so choose wisely to suit your personal style and needs.

Skin Tone Compatibility

In addition to weighing the shade range and versatility, the compatibility of a Too Faced eyeshadow palette with your skin tone is paramount when making a selection.

After all, what good are a bunch of gorgeous shades if they don’t flatter your complexion?

When evaluating skin tone compatibility, consider your undertones – are they warm, cool, or neutral?

Certain palettes, like the Chocolate Bar or Sweet Peach, lean warmer, while others like the Natural Eyes or Chocolate Bon Bons have more neutral tones.

If you have cool undertones, you’ll want to gravitate towards the latter.

Likewise, if you’ve got a warmer complexion, the former will be your best bet.

Don’t forget about depth of color, either.

Fairer skin tones may find heavily pigmented palettes like the Born This Way overbearing, while deeper skin tones might crave those same bold, high-impact shades.

The key is finding that Goldilocks balance – not too light, not too dark, but just right for your unique skin.

Price and Value

Evaluating the price-point and overall value proposition is a pivotal step when selecting a Too Faced eyeshadow palette that aligns with your budgetary constraints and cosmetic needs.

The brand’s palette offerings can span a wide range, from around $20 for smaller collections to over $60 for limited-edition, feature-rich products.

While the higher-priced palettes may seem indulgent, it’s vital to weigh the number of shades, quality of ingredients, and the potential longevity and versatility they provide.

Some palettes incorporate unique elements like real gold or coconut butter, which can contribute to the increased cost but offer specialized benefits.

Ultimately, the value of a Too Faced palette lies in its ability to deliver a high-performance formula and a diverse color selection that caters to your preferences and makeup requirements.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Do Too Faced Eyeshadow Palettes Typically Last?

You can expect Too Faced eyeshadow palettes to last around 1-2 years with regular use. The high-quality formulas and diverse color selections make these palettes a long-lasting investment in your makeup routine.

Do Too Faced Palettes Come With Applicator Brushes?

Yes, many Too Faced eyeshadow palettes come with applicator brushes. These brushes are typically small and basic, meant for application rather than blending. However, you’ll likely get better results using your own makeup brushes.

Can Too Faced Palettes Be Used by Those With Sensitive Skin?

You can use Too Faced palettes even if you have sensitive skin. They’re formulated with skin-nourishing ingredients and are gentle on the eyes. Just do a patch test first to guarantee they don’t irritate your delicate complexion.

How Do I Properly Clean Too Faced Eyeshadow Palettes?

To properly clean your Too Faced eyeshadow palette, gently sweep the surface with a clean, soft-bristled brush. Avoid using water or liquids, as this can damage the eyeshadows. Stored properly, your palette will stay fresh and vibrant.

Are Too Faced Palettes Cruelty-Free and Vegan?

Envision the vibrant eyeshadow hues – Too Faced palettes are cruelty-free and vegan, allowing you to create stunning looks without guilt. Their commitment to ethical practices guarantees you can indulge in their high-quality products with confidence.

Conclusion

Too Faced’s eyeshadow palettes are a veritable treasure trove for makeup enthusiasts.

Whether you’re seeking a classic matte look, dazzling metallics, or a peachy-keen vibe, there’s a palette to suit your every mood and whim.

With their unparalleled pigmentation and long-lasting wear, these eyeshadows are the crème de la crème of the cosmetic world.

So why not treat yourself to a little Too Faced indulgence and elevate your eye game to new heights?